(Credit: Imago)
(Credit: Imago)

West Ham player ratings vs Everton: 4/10 dreadful, Mateus Fernandes really steps up

Henry Green

Henry is a Football Writer for West Ham Zone. He finished studying Journalism at Nottingham Trent University in May, where he gained experience working for local news outlets, such as Notts TV and Nottinghamshire Live, as well as being sports editor for the student magazine. He started writing for Breaking Media in 2025.

Published on

West Ham managed to earn a draw against Everton on Monday in Nuno Espirito Santo's first game in charge.

Expectations were high at the Hill Dickinson Stadium, despite West Ham's 2-1 defeat to Crystal Palace last time out, thanks to Nuno's appointment.

James Ward-Prowse was left at home by Nuno, with supporters grateful for the announcement that he wasn't in the side.

The Hammers conceded their 14th goal of the season, but managed to show improvements, with Jarrod Bowen cancelling out the Toffees' goal.

Plenty of blame for the goal conceded can be placed on the shoulders of Konstantinos Mavropanos, as West Ham Zone rates each player’s performance out of 10.

Nuno Espirito Santo rubbing his hands together as Nottingham Forest manager
(Credit: Imago)

Mateus Fernandes lively vs Everton

Ward-Prowse's absence from the West Ham squad raised eyebrows after he became a regular under Graham Potter in the opening games.

However, Mateus Fernandes showed his quality from the start against the Toffees as he showed plenty of energy and control.

The Hammers looked completely different in midfield against a strong side, with Soungoutou Magassa and Mateus Fernandes working off each other well.

His midfield partner struggled in his first Premier League outing, but Fernandes made up for that.

Mateus Fernandes in a West Ham shirt
(Credit: Manh Tung, Breaking Media)

It will be interesting to see whether Nuno sticks with the pair in their next outing against Arsenal.

Konstantinos Mavropanos poor for West Ham

A lot has been said about the Hammers' centre-back pairings in recent weeks, having conceded 14 goals this season.

Max Kilman has already played under Nuno with Wolves, but didn't adapt well in the game, as they struggled to defend crosses.

  • Jack Grealish and Dewsbury-Hall caused problems for Mavropanos
  • The hosts had 11 shots against the Hammers' 12

It was Konstantinos Mavropanos who struggled the most in the Hammers' backline, as he lost his man when Michael Keane scored the opener.

The Irons have a reputation for conceding goals from corners this season, with six goals already conceded from set pieces.

However, it was the resultant cross from the corner that ended up finding the head of Keane.

The continued struggles at the back will concern Nuno, especially with a game against set-piece kings Arsenal coming up.

Konstantinos Mavropanos in action for West Ham
(Credit: Imago)

West Ham player ratings vs Everton

Alphonse Areola – 5

Kyle Walker-Peters – 4

Konstantinos Mavropanos – 4

Max Kilman – 5

Malick Diouf – 6

Soungoutou Magassa – 5

Jarrod Bowen – 7

Mateus Fernandes – 7

Crysencio Summerville – 6

Lucas Paqueta – 5

Niclas Fullkrug – 5

Substitutes:

Freddie Potts - 6

Luis Guilherme - 5

Igor Julio - N/A

Andy Irving - N/A

Enjoyed this article? Stay connected with all the latest West Ham United news, updates, and behind-the-scenes content by following us on our new Instagram account – @westhamzone247

www.westhamzone.com