Alan Shearer has commented on the West Ham's loss to Nottingham Forest
Alan Shearer has commented on the West Ham's loss to Nottingham Forest

Alan Shearer, Micah Richards in agreement over contentious West Ham v Man United moment

Dan Godfrey

Dan is a sports writer and broadcaster, who wrote for Breaking Media Limited's club sites between May 2024 and May 2025. Graduating from the University of Huddersfield in 2018 with First Class Honours in Sports Journalism, Dan has worked with several EFL clubs, as well as with BBC Radio, talkSPORT and TNT Sports. He previously resided in Sydney, Australia, where he continued his career as a freelance writer and broadcaster in various sports.

Published on

Alan Shearer and Micah Richards have slammed the decision to award West Ham United a penalty late on against Manchester United on Sunday [27 October].

Speaking on The Rest is Football podcast with Gary Lineker [28 October, 18m 05s], the duo criticised the officials for penalising Matthijs de Ligt for an alleged foul on Danny Ings, following a lengthy VAR review.

Shearer in particular called the decision "baffling", as Jarrod Bowen went on to score the spot-kick to secure the Hammers all three points in a 2-1 victory.

"You can look at it another 80 times and you're still never going to find anything," declared Shearer.

"The referee didn't give a penalty, then he's been told by VAR to go and have a look at the screen.

"But it's baffling that two experienced referees can look at that and think it's a penalty. It was a terrible decision and Man United would've looked at that and blamed that."

Richards added: "I agree with everything [Shearer said]. The only thing I would say is for the referee, when you get sent to the monitor, it does put doubt in your mind.

"There is contact, but there's not enough for a penalty."

Swings and roundabouts as West Ham United enjoy fortune

The debate will roll on all week as to whether there was anything in the incident between De Ligt and Ings.

The general consensus is that Julen Lopetegui's side were hugely fortunate, not just with the penalty call but also with the chances passed up by Manchester United.

There will come good and bad days for the Hammers this season - last weekend at Tottenham was a dismal afternoon across London - but this provided a potential springboard that Lopetegui desperately needed.

Danny Ings, West Ham
Danny Ings, West Ham striker

Winnable games are coming up against Nottingham Forest [2 November] and Everton [9 November], before the third international break of the campaign.

Mohammed Kudus remains banned for each of those, and it may just be time for Lopetegui to start Crysencio Summerville in the league after his substitute impact over the Red Devils.

For more West Ham news, follow us on Facebook or join our brand new WhatsApp Channel for instant updates to be sent straight to your phone.

www.westhamzone.com